Conjunction 20-49, 2020.
Tina Kim Gallery
A Spiritual Declaration, Under the weight of it all, 2021.
This year’s Frieze New York fair seems destined to be remembered as the art world’s beachhead in a post-pandemic world. Fourteen months after the last in-person art fair in New York City and two years after the last edition of Frieze New York, the fair’s organizers proved that, with enough health and safety measures in place, people will turn up to see art in person again. And they did—collectors, curators, and assorted art lovers queued up outside The Shed at their reserved times, with fresh COVID-19 test results or proof of vaccination in hand, to gain access to the fair’s 64 booths. Even New York City’s billionaire former mayor Michael Bloomberg, who pitched in $75 million of his own money to help build The Shed, had to show his credentials to get inside.
The fair itself was predictably muted, both in terms of the work on view and the energy in the aisles. There were about one-third the number of exhibitors that were typically packed into Frieze’s sprawling Randall’s Island tent in years past, and amply spread across three levels of The Shed. Most of the presentations were restrained, aside from ambitious interventions like Marian Goodman’s immersive Annette Messager installation or Sprüth Magers and Galerie Eva Presenhuber’s Gothic mise-en-scène for their joint showcase of Karen Kilimnik paintings and drawings. For obvious reasons, there were none of the grand gestures of Frieze New York’s past, like a sculptural installation in the form of a life-size city bus, a booth inhabited by a live donkey, or another that consisted entirely of a sales pitch for Soylent. The timed entry system also meant there wasn’t the frenetic, buzzing energy of a mega-fair from the pre-pandemic times.
Petite Babylone, 2019.
Marian Goodman Gallery
“It’s very different from years past; it’s not everybody lined up at the door, bum-rushing the fair at 11 a.m.,” said Rebecca Ann Siegel, Frieze’s director for the Americas and content. “The trade-off between that high-octane activity in the first hour has been these really fantastic conversations that people have been able to have, as visitors have been spread out throughout the day in a much more measured way.”
Within its constrained format—with fewer galleries offering works to fewer collectors visiting from a more geographically limited range of places—the fair was a success. Galleries reported strong sales, especially in the fair’s first days, aided by a general sense of collective giddiness at actually all being together again in the presence of art.
Sarah Ball, Anthony, 2020. Photo by Todd-White Art Photography. © Sarah Ball. Courtesy of the artist and Stephen Friedman Gallery, London.
“The inherent pace of the fair has changed, but I would say the greatest shift is that there’s a palpable excitement in the air, which definitely is more pronounced than in prior years,” said Perrotin principal partner and executive director Peggy Leboeuf. “Everyone is so grateful to be back, under the metaphorical art fair tent, and making sales.” Perrotin’s sales included a large glass sculpture by the French artist Jean-Michel Othoniel for $235,000, new paintings by Barry McGee and Daniel Arsham for $140,000 and $100,000, respectively, and a new charcoal composition by Lee Bae for $86,000.
For many dealers I spoke with, the change of pace was welcome, making it easier for them to connect (or reconnect) with collectors face-to-face after more than a year of only being able to do so remotely.
Study for the Red Portrait, 2017.
Tina Kim Gallery
“The structure of the fair this year takes some of the initial pressures off—we know that we will see our clients throughout the entire run of the fair, not just on the first day,” said gallerist Tina Kim. “Everyone is just so happy to be here and to be able to engage with art again, and that is reflected in the sales.” Her namesake gallery’s sales bore this out, with collectors snapping up two large paintings by Ha Chong-hyun and a work by Park Seo-bo, all in the range of $200,000 to $300,000, as well as three pieces by Suki Seokyeong Kang in the range of $25,000 to $50,000 each, and a Ghada Amer drawing for $45,000.
The fair’s solo booths, which accounted for many of its standout presentations, seemed to focus collectors’ attention and drive a significant share of sales. London’s Stephen Friedman Gallery, which opened a pop-up space nearby in Chelsea for the occasion, devoted its Frieze booth to portrait paintings by the British artist Sarah Ball, who joined the gallery’s roster in November. By the end of the fair’s first day, they’d all been sold for prices ranging from £15,000 to £35,000 (nearly $21,000 to over $48,000).
Ed Clark (1911-2000)
Hauser & Wirth
Bruise Painting “Blue Bird”, 2021.
Hauser & Wirth
“The confidence amongst collectors at Frieze New York is very encouraging, particularly during this difficult time,” said Mira Dimitrova, the gallery’s director of sales. “We have far more demand than we can satisfy at this point so will be continuing many of the conversations ahead of her first solo show at the gallery next year.”
The most notable sales made at the fair included the following:
- Hauser & Wirth sold a Louise Bourgeois bronze, Blind Man’s Buff (1984), for a price in the region of $1 million. The gallery also sold a new Rashid Johnson painting, Bruise Painting “Blue Bird” (2021), for $750,000, and an untitled Ed Clark painting from 1954 for $650,000.
- David Zwirner sold out its solo booth of paintings and sculptures by Dana Schutz, with paintings going for figures between $700,000 and $900,000 each, while the sculptures were priced between $160,000 and $250,000 apiece.
The Ventriloquist, 2021.
- Goodman Gallery sold William Kentridge’s monumental drawing Waiting for the Sibyl, (Comrade Tree, I report to you) (2020) for $700,000. The gallery also sold two quilt tapestries by Hank Willis Thomas—one to a private collection in Africa for $120,000 and the other to an Asian collection for $84,000—and a new painting by Cassi Namoda, A Spiritual Declaration Under the Weight of It All (2021), to an Asian museum for $25,000.
- Garth Greenan Gallery sold Jaune Quick-to-See Smith’s painting War Horse in Babylon (2005), which was priced between $100,000 and $250,000, and Derek Boshier’s large tapestry America, America (2018), priced between $50,000 and $100,000.
Drawing for Waiting for the Sibyl (It’s too late now), 2019.
- James Cohan Gallery sold 11 works from its solo booth of works by Trenton Doyle Hancock for prices between $5,500 and $60,000. Buyers included institutions in Canada and on the East Coast of the United States, as well as private collectors in New York, Los Angeles, and the Midwest.
- Sprüth Magers and Galerie Eva Presenhuber sold multiple pieces from their Karen Kilimnik solo booth, with paintings going for prices between $60,000 and $175,000, and drawings priced from $15,000 to $110,000.
Sean Kelly Gallery
- New York’s Sean Kelly Gallery sold an intricate work on paper by Shahzia Sikander, Mirrored (2019), for $125,000. The gallery also sold an edition of the photograph A Girl with School Medals (1988) by Dawoud Bey—whose retrospective at the Whitney Museum opened last month, about one mile south of The Shed—for $15,000.
- Wilding Cran sold five works from its solo presentation of sculptures by Karon Davis in the fair’s Frame sector, with prices ranging from $38,000 to $40,000.
A Girl with School Medals, 1988.
Sean Kelly Gallery
Another distinguishing feature of the fair was its reliance on a strong turnout from local collectors. Whereas past editions of Frieze New York—and the bevy of fairs typically timed to coincide with it like 1-54 and TEFAF New York—could reliably draw collectors from around the globe, travel restrictions and health concerns made for a distinctly regional turnout.
“It’s mainly New York collectors, I’d say 80 percent [from] New York,” said Jorg Grimm, whose gallery seemed to find success with the local clientele. GRIMM sold Daniel Richter’s recent canvas Mainness (2021) for €200,000 (over $240,000), Louise Giovanelli’s painting Orbiter (2021) for $30,000, Claudia Martínez Garay’s abuelitas (2021) for $10,000, and five works by Arturo Kameya for prices between $3,500 and $5,000.
Claudia Martínez Garay
Beyond the contingent of committed New Yorkers, gallerists said the collectors making the trek to The Shed tended to be coming from California, Texas, the Midwest, and Florida—including Miami’s Don and Mera Rubell, who plied the aisles on opening day. “I was expecting a tristate-area audience and was happily surprised to learn that many of my clients were planning on traveling for the fair,” said Jessica Kreps, a partner at Lehmann Maupin. “During the week, we were able to meet with clients from Los Angeles, Dallas, Chicago, San Francisco, and Miami. We even had a client travel from Jakarta!”
The gallery’s intrepid patrons came ready to buy. Lehmann Maupin reported selling three paintings by Dominic Chambers for prices between $35,000 and $40,000, including one to a collector in Florida and another to a Canadian collector; two new works by Gilbert & George priced at £60,000 (nearly $84,000) apiece, one of them to a Boston-based collector; a large McArthur Binion work, Modern:Ancient:Brown (2020), in the range of of $160,000 to $200,000, to a collector based in Palm Beach (where the gallery has a seasonal outpost); and the booth’s centerpiece, The Suspect (2021), a six-panel painted folding screen by Hernan Bas, to a European collector for a price in the range of $350,000 to $400,000.
The Suspect, 2021.
“The ongoing travel restrictions are real, and being able to reach audiences digitally, who are abroad, as well as our local audience at The Shed, has been really wonderful,” said Siegel, noting that the fair’s offerings extend beyond the 64 physical booths at Hudson Yards to more than 160 digital presentations on Frieze’s online viewing room platform. “For galleries, this moment has been as much of a return as we can possibly have at this point.”
Notable sales made through Frieze’s online viewing rooms included the following:
- New York’s 303 Gallery sold a Doug Aitken lightbox work for $225,000, a painting by Hans-Peter Feldmann for €130,000 ($158,000), a Rodney Graham painting for $125,000, and a sculpture by Alicja Kwade for €52,000 (over $63,000).
- Brussels gallery Xavier Hufkens sold a Thomas Houseago sculpture for $375,000; a work on paper and a neon by Tracey Emin for $32,000 and $105,000, respectively; and a Katherine Bernhardt painting for $65,000.
Appearance of Crosses 2021-B2, 2021.
Ding Yi 丁乙
Appearance of Crosses 2021-B5, 2021.
Ding Yi 丁乙
- New York’s Timothy Taylor sold three paintings by Ding Yi for $130,000 apiece, as well as multiple drawings by the artist for $45,000.
- Los Angeles’s Kohn Gallery sold two works by Memphis-based artist Jarvis Boyland for prices between $20,000 and $50,000; one of them, the painting Fool’s Errand #3 (2021), was acquired by a major New York institution. The gallery also sold a Heidi Hahn painting for $40,000, a painting by Rosa Loy for $30,000, and a Kate Barbee painting for $25,000.
New York’s first in-person COVID-19-era art fair is in the books, and it made clear that collectors’ appetites weren’t diminished by the pandemic. The next major measure of the art market’s resurgence begins tomorrow, when Christie’s and Sotheby’s hold their marquee spring auctions in New York, which are expected to bring in upwards of $1 billion. Ten days later, Art Basel returns to Hong Kong, arguably the most resilient art market capital over the past year—yet another signal that the art world may be poised to return stronger than it was at the beginning of 2020.